Test Comparisons

 

Allergy testing is performed to establish whether atopy is the basis for allergy-like symptoms and to identify potential specific etiology, which should lead to appropriate therapeutic recommendations. Two types of diagnostic tests are available for measuring allergen-specific IgE—
in vitro IgE blood testing and in vivo skin testing.

An important diagnostic tool
A careful patient history, in addition to a physical examination, provides important clues to the physician. In vitro tests that measure the presence of IgE antibodies can be used to identify atopic individuals, determine the specific allergens to which they are sensitive, and assess their risk for evolution of more serious diseases.1 In vivo tests can also be used, although they are dependent on the experience of the tester and the quality of the extracts used.1 In addition, this form of testing requires that the patient discontinue antihistamines and other medications at least 3 days before using,1,2 and may be hazardous to the highly sensitized patient.1

Blood testing technology
Allergen-specific in vitro blood testing is an easy procedure that is at least equivalent to skin testing in efficacy.1,2 It can be performed in the physician's office lab (CLIA moderate license) or sent to one of hundreds of reference labs. With this kind of testing, the patient need not discontinue medications.

Not all in vitro tests are alike, however. The most accurate and commonly used technology, ImmunoCAP Specific IgE blood test, is vastly superior to RAST™ technology, which was first introduced by Pharmacia in 1974.

ImmunoCAP has been cleared by the FDA as a truly quantitative measure of IgE.

ImmunoCAP Specific IgE blood test provides:

  • More true positives than RAST
  • Higher sensitivity than RAST
  • True negatives (no significant atopy)
  • Consistently acceptable coefficient of determination (R2) values 3

Accuracy of Immunoassays for Specific IgE

In clinical tests, ImmunoCAP technology has been demonstrated to be close to an ideal lab determination.

In a key comparison study,3 illustrated above, laboratories evaluated more than 12,000 blinded serum samples containing various levels of specific IgE, using a number of lab tests in order to compare accuracy and precision.

ImmunoCAP technology produced the best assessments at 96-98% of the ideal standard. RAST tests ranged from 65-82%. As the researchers concluded, ImmunoCAP performed well when compared with the standard of an ideal assay, although other assays often did not perform up to this standard.